Due to an undescended testicle, my invasive vasectomy two years ago failed. I want to be sterile and keep my testicle. What are my options?

An in-office vasectomy was not possible, so I was placed under general anesthesia and my undescended testicle was temporarily removed from my scrotum so that the vas deferens could be cut. The doctor was uncertain if the correct tube was cut after the surgery, and my most recent sperm motility test showed 1 per HPF and 66% motility. I was told that the only real solution now is to remove the testicle completely, but it might lower my libido. Reattempting might cut an artery. Any advice?

Answers from doctors (5)


More About Doctor John C. McHugh, MD

Published on Sep 09, 2019

Based on the 1 sperm per high-powered field, it appears the vasectomy was performed but the sperm has not cleared. This, unfortunately, is not uncommon.

The usual advice is to ejaculate as much as possible and repeat the specimen until clear.

The internet is replete with articles about sperm not completely clearing after vasectomy. I'd advise reviewing those articles and speaking with your urologist.

Of note, some feel sterility is achieved with less than 100,000 per HPF, however, we all would prefer zero sperm prior to giving the go-ahead for unprotected sex. Another note, 20 million sperm seen on a semen analysis is felt to be the low range number to achieve pregnancy.

Answered by John C. McHugh, MD (View Profile)

Based on the 1 sperm per high-powered field, it appears the vasectomy was performed but the sperm has not cleared. This, unfortunately, is not uncommon.

The usual advice is to ejaculate as much as possible and repeat the specimen until clear.

The internet is replete with articles about sperm not completely clearing after vasectomy. I'd advise reviewing those articles and speaking with your urologist.

Of note, some feel sterility is achieved with less than 100,000 per HPF, however, we all would prefer zero sperm prior to giving the go-ahead for unprotected sex. Another note, 20 million sperm seen on a semen analysis is felt to be the low range number to achieve pregnancy.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Steven K. Sterzer, MD

Published on Jun 15, 2016

A few issues here. Since you describe your undescended testicle is in the scrotum, I assume you had surgery in the past to put it the scrotum. If so, there likely is scar tissue in the spermatic cord, which contains the blood vessels and vas. This makes it quite difficult at times to locate the vas in the scar tissue, and hence the vas may have been misidentified at the time of vasectomy. Also, we don't know how long after the vasectomy your sperm sample check occurred. It may be that in time your sperm count will go to zero. It may be worthwhile to get a formal semen analysis since it is also possible that you have an extremely low sperm count and other adverse sperm health parameters to make all of this moot. If still potentially fertile, you might want to have another urologist assess your situation.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/5068_1500497969.jpg
Answered by Steven K. Sterzer, MD

A few issues here. Since you describe your undescended testicle is in the scrotum, I assume you had surgery in the past to put it the scrotum. If so, there likely is scar tissue in the spermatic cord, which contains the blood vessels and vas. This makes it quite difficult at times to locate the vas in the scar tissue, and hence the vas may have been misidentified at the time of vasectomy. Also, we don't know how long after the vasectomy your sperm sample check occurred. It may be that in time your sperm count will go to zero. It may be worthwhile to get a formal semen analysis since it is also possible that you have an extremely low sperm count and other adverse sperm health parameters to make all of this moot. If still potentially fertile, you might want to have another urologist assess your situation.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Marc Goldstein, MD, FACS

Published on Jun 14, 2016

The vasectomy should be done under the microscope so the artery and vas can be seen. Unless pathology was done showing a vas was missed, both sides should be redone. No reason to remove the testicle.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/4457_1426036347.jpg
Answered by Marc Goldstein, MD, FACS

The vasectomy should be done under the microscope so the artery and vas can be seen. Unless pathology was done showing a vas was missed, both sides should be redone. No reason to remove the testicle.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Wayne B. Glazier, MD, FACS

Published on Jun 14, 2016

If the pathology revealed that in fact a piece of vas was obtained from the undescended testicle, re-exploration of scrotum in attempt to locate vas on each side is the only option. Understand that undescended testes might need to be removed because of scarring and prior surgery. If the other testicle is normal, however, removal of the testes is unlikely to lower libido.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/7320_1501017646.jpg
Answered by Wayne B. Glazier, MD, FACS

If the pathology revealed that in fact a piece of vas was obtained from the undescended testicle, re-exploration of scrotum in attempt to locate vas on each side is the only option. Understand that undescended testes might need to be removed because of scarring and prior surgery. If the other testicle is normal, however, removal of the testes is unlikely to lower libido.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Ranjith Ramasamy M.D.

Published on Jun 14, 2016

It depends on where the other testis is, and you certainly need to be re-explored. Using a microscope can aid in distinction between vas and the remaining spermatic cord.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/7735_1454968857.jpg
Answered by Ranjith Ramasamy M.D.

It depends on where the other testis is, and you certainly need to be re-explored. Using a microscope can aid in distinction between vas and the remaining spermatic cord.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Related Questions for Vasectomy

Vasectomy -9 answers
She does not know i had a vasectomy. What should i do?
See More
Vasectomy -5 answers
Will it cause any harm even though i have no intercourse?
See More
Vasectomy -7 answers
After the vasectomy procedure, am I infertile right away? Or do I need to wait for a certain amount of time to pass after the procedure?
See More
Vasectomy -4 answers
My doctor says to wait two weeks before ANY kind of sexual activity. The literature says one week. Can ejaculation cause damage to the vas deferens if it's too soon?
See More
Get answers from our experienced doctors.
How it works
Vasectomy -7 answers
I want to make sure the ends do not reconnect and my count remains at 0.
See More
Vasectomy -6 answers
Why are my testicles still sore after 2 1/2 months? They feel as if they have been flicked or kicked. They are very sensitive.
See More
Vasectomy -13 answers
I would like to get a vasectomy after we're done having children, but am worried that it will affect our sex life.
See More
Vasectomy -9 answers
I am a veteran who is covered by the VA. However, the VA does not cover vasectomies, so I'd have to pay for the procedure out-of-pocket. How much does a vasectomy cost?
See More
Vasectomy -4 answers
After a vasectomy, is it normal for it to swell to the size of a baseball on just 1 side?
See More
Get answers from our experienced doctors.
How it works

Related Articles

Have specific questions?
ASK A DOCTOR