Husband has sperm 8 months after vasectomy. Did the procedure fail?

My husband had a vasectomy 8 months ago he has had more then 40 ejaculation since his surgery, or maybe even more. The semen analysis came back with more then 20 hpf. Motile and non motile sperm were seen. Could his vasectomy have failed, or can it take a long time to become sterile? Thank you.

Answers from doctors (2)


Robert G. Pugach, M.D.

Published on Aug 26, 2017

Yes. The American Urological Association says that, if there are sperm 6 months after a vasectomy, the procedure should be considered unsuccessful and a repeat procedure should be performed.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/8461_1503352272.jpg
Answered by Robert G. Pugach, M.D.

Yes. The American Urological Association says that, if there are sperm 6 months after a vasectomy, the procedure should be considered unsuccessful and a repeat procedure should be performed.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


More About Doctor John C. McHugh, MD

Published on Aug 15, 2017

There two scenarios here. It is possible that the vasectomy has successfully divided the vas and that the sperm are, for whatever reason, slow to completely clear. If this is the thinking you would re check after another twenty or so ejaculations. On the other hand this may represent a recanalization of the vas tubes, a small channel, that has reconnected the vas tubes. In this case another vasectomy would be performed. A couple of things: You could have a formal semen analysis performed to actually get a count, it is possible that 20 per highpower field correlates with a very low total count. Some feel that after a vasectomy less than 100,000 on a semen analysis is acceptable. I have experienced you particular situation about five times in my career and I have repeated the vasectomy. Interestingly each time it corrected the small numbers of sperm that persistently showed up on microscopic exam.

Answered by John C. McHugh, MD (View Profile)

There two scenarios here. It is possible that the vasectomy has successfully divided the vas and that the sperm are, for whatever reason, slow to completely clear. If this is the thinking you would re check after another twenty or so ejaculations. On the other hand this may represent a recanalization of the vas tubes, a small channel, that has reconnected the vas tubes. In this case another vasectomy would be performed. A couple of things: You could have a formal semen analysis performed to actually get a count, it is possible that 20 per highpower field correlates with a very low total count. Some feel that after a vasectomy less than 100,000 on a semen analysis is acceptable. I have experienced you particular situation about five times in my career and I have repeated the vasectomy. Interestingly each time it corrected the small numbers of sperm that persistently showed up on microscopic exam.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Related Questions for Vasectomy

Vasectomy -9 answers
She does not know i had a vasectomy. What should i do?
See More
Vasectomy -5 answers
Will it cause any harm even though i have no intercourse?
See More
Vasectomy -7 answers
After the vasectomy procedure, am I infertile right away? Or do I need to wait for a certain amount of time to pass after the procedure?
See More
Vasectomy -4 answers
My doctor says to wait two weeks before ANY kind of sexual activity. The literature says one week. Can ejaculation cause damage to the vas deferens if it's too soon?
See More
Get answers from our experienced doctors.
How it works
Vasectomy -7 answers
I want to make sure the ends do not reconnect and my count remains at 0.
See More
Vasectomy -6 answers
Why are my testicles still sore after 2 1/2 months? They feel as if they have been flicked or kicked. They are very sensitive.
See More
Vasectomy -13 answers
I would like to get a vasectomy after we're done having children, but am worried that it will affect our sex life.
See More
Vasectomy -9 answers
I am a veteran who is covered by the VA. However, the VA does not cover vasectomies, so I'd have to pay for the procedure out-of-pocket. How much does a vasectomy cost?
See More
Vasectomy -4 answers
After a vasectomy, is it normal for it to swell to the size of a baseball on just 1 side?
See More
Get answers from our experienced doctors.
How it works

Related Articles

Have specific questions?
ASK A DOCTOR